Mailbag! The Great Butter Debate SOLVED

Dear Living Well Daily Reader,

You’ve got questions…

We’ve got answers!

We get lots of food questions in the mailbag, but there’s been one that comes up again and again — which is better, butter or margarine?

So today, we are dedicating this reader mail segment to resolving the Great Butter Debate. Plus, we will give you a few tips on how to select a heart-healthy spread.

Let’s dive in…

The Great Butter Debate: Cows vs. Chemicals

Hi Natalie,

For many years, I’ve been eating margarine because the labels say “heart healthy.” However, recently, I’ve heard that it’s made from pretty dangerous ingredients. Is butter actually healthier than margarine? If so, do you know what kind I should be buying?

Thanks,

Etta S.

Thanks for the great question, Etta. Many readers have questions about butter and margarine.

Let’s start by defining them.

Butter is a dairy product made by churning milk or cream. Eventually, the fatty solids will separate from the liquid. These fatty solids are butter, and the liquids are buttermilk. This means butter has only one natural ingredient. If it’s salted butter, then it will have two natural ingredients.

Margarine was designed to be a cheap butter replacement and is often made from GMO soybean oil and other cheap oils like canola or palm oil.

But the bad news doesn’t end there… since these oils are typically liquid at room temperature, margarine is often hydrogenated. This process turns these already not-so-healthy oils into even more dangerous trans fats.

Trans fats can raise your LDL (bad) cholesterol and significantly lower your HDL (good) cholesterol. Plus, even though some margarines are trans fat free, they’re still full of chemicals like emulsifiers, artificial flavors and colorants. Most margarines contain around 10 ingredients.

So just by comparing ingredients, it looks like butter is the better choice. But you’ve probably heard it’s terrible for your heart because of its high levels of cholesterol and saturated fats.

Well, there are a few studies that prove that’s simply not true…

Recent research shows that eating saturated fats or cholesterol won’t affect your cholesterol levels. In fact, these two natural fats can increase your good cholesterol and even change your bad cholesterol to a harmless type of fat that isn’t linked to heart disease.

But not all butter is created equal.

Conventionally raised dairy cows are given hormones and antibiotics, are fed grains and are frequently milked. All of these factors can lead to less nutritious dairy products.

That’s why it’s important to look for butter from grass-fed cows. Not only is it much more nutritious than butter from grain-fed cows, but it’s also rich in vitamin K2 and omega-3 fatty acids. Both of these nutrients are vital for heart health and may even prevent heart issues. While grass-fed organic butter is optimal, it’s not always easy to find.

Organic Valley Pasture Butter is one brand that is both grass-fed and organic. If you can’t find that, Kerrygold is at least grass-fed, though it’s not organic.

Organic butter that’s not grass-fed is your next best choice. For a dairy product to be labelled organic, the USDA requires that the cows be put on pasture for the grazing season a minimum of 120 days per year. Farmers also have to have a pasture management plan in place to protect the fields, soil and water quality. Any supplemental feed must be organic and non-GMO, and the cows cannot be given antibiotics or growth hormones.

Most grocers offer at least one type of organic butter.

Last, there’s conventional grain-fed butter. While this is in last place for butter options since it might can contain milk from grain-fed cows that were given antibiotics and hormones, it still beats margarine by a landslide.

So when given the choice, always choose cows over chemicals.

Do you have any health questions you want answered? Drop me a line nmoore@lfb.org

Live well,

Natalie Moore
Managing editor, Living Well Daily

Ed. Note: Please send your feedback: nmoore@lfb.org – and click here to like us on Facebook.


Sources

[1] Butter vs Margarine – Why I Trust Cows More Than Chemists

[2] How To Survive The Supermarket

[3] Guidelines for Organic Certification of Dairy Livestock

Natalie Moore

Written By Natalie Moore

Natalie Moore is a dedicated health researcher with a passion for finding healthy, natural, and science-based solutions. After a decade of direct healthcare experience in western and natural medicine, she was involved in public health research before joining Living Well Daily.

View More Free Articles

The Deadly Danger Lurking in Your Favorite Foods

I’m sure it comes as no surprise that the so-called Western diet isn’t doing you any favors. You know the one I’m talking about—burgers, fries, sugary sodas, and processed snacks galore. It’s the diet that’s as American as apple pie (which, ironically, isn’t great for us either). But let’s face it, despite knowing it isn’t...

Read This

The Nightly Brain Reset You Can't Afford to Miss

We know sleep is vital. It’s right up there with eating your vegetables and regular exercise. But let’s be honest—many of us don’t prioritize it as we should. We’re up in the middle of the night binge-watching our favorite shows or tossing and turning, struggling to sleep. Then, when we wake up feeling irritable and...

Read This

Olive Oil “Trash” Is a “Treasure” For Your Health

You probably know that olive oil is a superstar ingredient in the Mediterranean diet. Its health benefits range from supporting heart health to reducing inflammation and protecting against certain cancers. But you know how they say one man’s trash is another man’s treasure? Well, in the case of a waste product from olive oil production,...

Read This

Low Carb Delivers HIGH Nutritional Rewards

If you’re a regular Living Well Daily reader, you know I’m a big fan of low-carb eating. But I’m NOT talking about those extreme “meat-only” diets you might have heard about Instead, I encourage focusing on quality proteins and non-starchy veggies to keep your blood sugar in check and promote longevity. But I’m met with...

Read This

Are Electrolyte Sports Drinks REALLY Healthy?

You’ve undoubtedly seen the colorful sports drinks lining grocery store shelves. They promise to replenish our electrolytes and boost our performance. But are these trendy beverages really the health elixirs they claim to be? Keep reading to uncover the surprising truth about electrolytes and their impact on your health… Electrolytes are minerals in your blood...

Read This

The TRUTH About Winter Weight Gain

Happy New Year! If you’re like many folks, you woke up today thinking about the year ahead, determined to turn over a new leaf. In fact, the number one New Year’s resolution year after year is to lose some weight. Common wisdom claims that putting on five pounds over the winter is inevitable. But is...

Read This

Mailbag: 3 “Cocktail Companions” to Safely Ring in the New Year

“I don’t usually drink alcohol. But I’m going to a New Year’s party and might have a few drinks. Can I do anything to make them less harmful to my health?” -Cheering In the New Year Hi Cheering, As you prepare for your New Year’s celebration tonight, you may be looking forward to raising a...

Read This

Could a Fall Be a Warning Sign for Something WORSE?

Falls are an unfortunate reality for many older adults. They’re among the most common causes of injuries and hospital visits for seniors. But what if a fall could mean something more? New research raises concerns that falls might be more than just a physical issue—they could be an early warning sign of a devastating condition…...

Read This

Want to Live Longer? Reach for Your Toes

We know that staying active is crucial for healthy aging. But what if touching your toes might be just as critical as taking your daily walk? Surprised? Well, new research suggests that flexibility could be the secret ingredient to a longer, healthier life. A groundbreaking study from Brazil uncovered a fascinating link between flexibility and...

Read This

Tiny Toxic Threat Lurking in the Air You Breathe

Imagine taking a deep breath of fresh air, only to realize that—along with oxygen—you’re also inhaling tiny plastic particles. It may sound like a scene from a science-fiction film, but new research reveals microplastics have found their way into the very air we breathe—and they may pose serious risks to your health. Recently, scientists discovered...

Read This