“Universal” Failure: Public Health’s Answer to Prevention

  • What is herd immunity doing (or not doing) for you?
  • What are Americans doing almost as much as paying taxes?
  • Fever, aches, paralysis – Oh, my!

Dear reader,

Picture it.

Every staff member in the emergency room is covered head to toe in masks, gowns and gloves.

Patients spread about the ER bays — the worst cases rushed to isolation rooms.

Families, particularly those with children, told to leave for their own protection.

Medications and vaccines stockpiled in nurses stations so quickly pharmacy can’t fill the orders.

Instantly, emails fly out to all of the floors.

Administrators, VPs, infection control specialists, and department managers frantically making emergency census plans, hiring more part-time staff.

Frantically adding employees to on-call lists — preparing for the certain onslaught of sick patients and inevitable nursing staff absences.

What kind of outbreak could cause such madness?



The plague?!


As a mental health triage screener, this is the scene I observed each year since the first case of influenza rolled into the ER.

Managers instructed (bullied) their workers to take the vaccination as fast as humanly possible.

The flu shot was mandatory for anyone working in the hospital, even those not in direct patient care. If you were to decline the shot, you had to sign a form stating you chose to forego it.

This hospital, like most others, made it clear that you were not going to have an excused absence if you missed work due to contracting the flu and had declined the shot.

Every year but two, I declined.

The two years I took the shot, I lived with a family member who has a chronic illness. I never believed the shot worked, but his doctor did. While it certainly went against my principles to take the vaccine, it was what had to happen at the time.

Those two years, I got sick — something that never happened in the years I rejected the vaccine.

I experienced flu-like symptoms in the days after taking the shot — common side effect, amongst other more severe ones, we will dig deeper into a bit later.

I witnessed many co-workers and patients suffer the flu even though they had the vaccination.

First-hand evidence of how mass vaccination did not combat the spread of the influenza virus.

And what is worse, most of these folks experienced side effects and still have no immunity for at least two weeks.

I would often wonder how was this happening if all those folks got the flu shot? Why did I keep hearing “herd immunity”? What does the medical establishment actually know about this virus? What is in this vaccine?

Should I risk my current good health on a vaccine that may harm me more than help me?

Flu Shot Frenzy — “Protecting” the Herd

These days, you can’t hide from the flu shot. Advertisements are at every turn. Blurbs on the television, radio, billboards, and buses — the constant reminders that we all need the shot or risk being one of the estimated 3,000 – 49,000 flu-related deaths.1

The shot is available everywhere. Once only found at medical facilities, you can now find it in pharmacies, schools, big-box stores, grocers, and drive-thrus — even in airports. What’s next? Your first bag flies free when you take the flu shot?

Over 500 infectious diseases affect humans, but U.S. public health officials recommend vaccination for just 17 of them. Of these 17, only is “universal” (recommended for all): the flu shot 2.

As of 2010, the Advisory Committee on Immunizations Practices (ACIP) recommends all persons over 6 month of age get the flu shot — a knee-jerk response to the 2009 H1NI flu pandemic which caused 151,700 – 575,400 deaths worldwide 3. Hmmm… a 400,000 range in a death estimate.  What are a few hundred thousand lives to a public health authority?

In fact, the University of Minnesota’s Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy completed the Comprehensive Influenza Vaccine Initiative (a comprehensive study of flu shot data) and had this to say about the ACIP’s recommendation:

“In an effort to reduce influenza morbidity and mortality, over the last three decades the ACIP has expanded the populations recommended to receive influenza vaccine. These recommendations, however, often were based on professional judgement and not on scientifically sound data.”

So what is the benefit of immunizing a majority of the population?

Allegedly, it creates herd immunity.

Herd immunity is a popular concept public health agencies use to sway people into vaccinations. The herd immunity principle claims an entire population experiences more protection by partial immunization of a population than none at all.

Vaccines.gov describes herd immunity as:

“When a critical portion of a community is immunized against a contagious disease, most members of the community are protected against that disease because there is little opportunity for an outbreak. Even those who are not eligible for certain vaccines — such as infants, pregnant women, or immunocompromised individuals — get some protection because the spread of contagious disease is contained 4.”

Translation: Group protection at the cost of individual health.

While there is some controversy on the efficacy of herd immunity and not a whole lot of science to back it, this diagram shows how it should work.

Diagram from www.pediatricsconsultantlive.com

But does this work if the vaccine is only 19 percent effective?

That’s right…

The 2014 flu vaccine at greatest estimate was 19 percent effective.5

Meaning getting the vaccine reduced one’s of chances contracting the flu by a meager 19 percent and leaves an 81 percent chance of getting it.

Lots of losers in that herd — unless you are Big Pharma.

The flu virus strains used for the inoculation were a bad match for the active virus

Basically, the creators of the vaccine put all of their chips on the wrong strain.

So why all of the panic and vaccine pushing if it’s only going to leave a gaping 81 percent hole in the herd?

Money, duh.

Low Protection, High Profits

2013 yielded $3.1 billion in flu shot sales for Big Pharma. 6

Many have said this figure is small in comparison to other drugs Big Pharma pushes. But that’s like saying one bank robbery is smaller than another.

How many businesses are going to turn away their cut of a $3.1 billion profit?

Not to mention their buddies over at the CDC do a great job of convincing most people they need this vaccine to be safe from the flu. And the FDA assures it’s totally safe.

Their friends at retail pharmacies are in on the campaign as well.

Walgreens’ January 2013 sales jumped 6 percent thanks to pharmacists being able to give the shot.

Prices for a single flu shot at Walgreens vary from $31.99 – 59.99 but that’s not the only big motivation for drug stores. If they can get customers in for vaccinations, chances are they can get you purchase household items and groceries, thus increasing their profits even more.

All told, 47.1 percent of Americans took last season’s almost worthless vaccine.7

That’s over 150 million people.

That seems like a lot.

It is.

To put this in perspective, roughly 166 million Americans pay taxes.8

Almost as many people are willing to get the shot as they are to shell out a penny to Uncle Sam.

Surely there are large profits for companies selling and distributing a product purchased by almost half of the country.

And what exactly are they selling us?

 More Than Just a Dead Virus

Most flu vaccinations contain viruses cultured in eggs. Though, there is an alternative vaccine available for those who have poultry allergies.

The shots contains either three or four different strains of the virus depending the type of shot.

But the ingredients don’t stop with dead viruses and eggs.

There are toxic inactive ingredients in the vaccines as well.

Vaccine-makers use formaldehyde in vaccines to inactivate the virus strains.  Per the International Agency for Research on Cancer, formaldehyde is a human carcinogen.10  Who wants to inject themselves with a carcinogen?

And the dangers don’t stop there.

Another inactive ingredient is octylphenol ethoxylate, a product used in paints. It’s very toxic to aquatic wildlife and likely disrupts hormone functions in animals.

There are few studies about its exact effects on humans. Logic would say if it’s bad for animals, it’s probably bad for humans. 11

But wait, there’s more…

Multidose vials of the flu shot contain mercury.

Thimerosal is a preservative in the multi-dose vials of the flu immunization and is about 50 percent mercury by weight.

As of 2002, thimerosal is no longer in childhood vaccines thanks to a joint effort by the CDC, FDA, NIH, Health Resources and Services Administration HRSA and the American Academy of Pediatrics.

These agencies urged vaccine-makers to remove the mercury-based product “just in case” there was a link to autism.12

Why allow it in any vaccine, then? Particularly the only “universal” vaccine.

What kind of side effects could these toxic ingredients cause in our bodies?

The truth is, we don’t know a whole lot. I was unable to find any studies on the combined inactive ingredients – this further complicates understanding the full range of negative health endpoints.

And, wait a minute… there hasn’t been one person in my life, close, distant or even a patient — who has died from the flu…

Vaccination Considerations

The vast range of 3,000-49,000 estimated annual deaths from seasonal flu is interesting. The CDC allows for such a range due to the inaccuracy in the reporting of deaths from seasonal flu and death certificates rarely listing the flu as cause of death.

If it’s so dangerous, why don’t they make hospitals report it? Reporting is required for many diseases including rabies and chickenpox.

It is factual the flu virus can aggravate certain chronic diseases such as chronic pulmonary disease and cardiovascular disease but rarely is the flu the single cause of death.

These massive ranges allow for the CDC to use big, scary numbers that are mostly inaccurate. However, they do provide encouraging data for the flu shot campaign.

Common side effects listed for the flu shot include soreness, redness and swelling at the shot site; low- grade fever; and aches. While it won’t give you the flu, it can certainly make you feel rotten for a few days.

Dr. Wayne Gorsek of Dr. Vita had this to say about the flu shot’s effects on the body:

“The latest studies I’ve seen on the flu shot show it does not work and it actually increases your risk of getting the flu because what it does is it weakens your immune system. It actually causes your immune system to go after the alleged invaders in that flu shot and you’ve got a certain amount of fire power. Just like a gun only has a certain amount of ammo. And when you use up that ammo, you don’t have anything to use against the real invader.”

He went on to add, “I do not get flu shots, I don’t give them to my children and no way, no how.”

But that is not the worst that can happen.

Guillain- Barre syndrome is a disorder that causes the immune system to attack the body’s nerve cells. These attacks can cause muscle weakness and even paralysis. In 1976, cases of Guillain-Barre were associated with the swine flu vaccine.

While it is not completely clear if current vaccination have the same correlation, there were a total of 128 cases filed in vaccine court between November 2013 and February 2014. Of these, 52 received compensation and 40 arranged settlements.14  These are just the reported cases. It would be to reason there are many more out there.

And what is more disappointing — the shot is not effective for up to two weeks. Meaning you could still contract the flu virus, especially if there is an outbreak in your community.

Doing the math here makes the flu shot seem like an irrelevant precaution. Likely low efficacy after a two-week waiting period with the possibility of illness or strange neurological syndromes. Why even bother?

The lacking science about its efficacy, its toxic ingredients and the horrifying side effect seem to make it a no-brainer — don’t take it.

But making the choice to get the flu shot can be very personal matter.

The little gray areas in life can make a decision like this a little trickier. If you are in a situation, as I was, where another person’s health or beliefs are involved in your choice, be sure to take time and evaluate the pros and cons — both for your health and theirs.

If you choose the shot or not, be sure to take care of yourself during flu season. Rest, hydrate, eat well and boost your immune system naturally. If you know there is an outbreak in your community, stay home as much as you can.

A healthy immune system is your best defense!

Live well,

Natalie Moore
Managing editor, Living Well Daily

P.S. Try this easy recipe to keep your immune health in check!

Immune Boosting Cocktail

1 Teaspoon apple cider vinegar

1 cup holy basil tea

1 lemon slice

1 pinch grated ginger

½ teaspoon raw honey or to taste

Steep holy basil tea for 10 minutes. Add in ACV and honey, stir. Then, garnish with lemon and grated ginger.

This tea cocktail is perfect for first thing in the morning to get your immune system working and also a good as an immune restorative before bed.

P.P.S. Write in with any question or comments about your flu experiences or with any subjects you would like to see in future articles! nmoore@lfb.org


[1] Key Facts About Seasonal Flu Vaccine

[2] The Compelling Need For Game-Changing Influenza Vaccines

[3] First Global Estimates of 2009 H1N1 Pandemic Mortality Released by CDC-Led Collaboration

[4] Community Immunity (“Herd Immunity”)

[5] CDC Presents Updated Estimates of Flu Vaccine Effectiveness for the 2014-2015 Season

[6] Quadrivalents Boost Flu Vaccine Sales

[7] Flu Vaccination Coverage, United States, 2014-15 Influenza Season

[8] In 2015, 45 Percent Of Americans Will Pay No Federal Income Taxes

[9] Highlights of Prescribing Information

[10] National Cancer Institute

[11] National Biomonitoring Program

[12] Thimerosal in Vaccines

[13] Report from the
Department of Justice

Natalie Moore

Written By Natalie Moore

Natalie Moore is a dedicated health researcher with a passion for finding healthy, natural, and science-based solutions. After a decade of direct healthcare experience in western and natural medicine, she was involved in public health research before joining Living Well Daily.

View More Free Articles

Missing Out on These SURPRISING Pumpkin Benefits?

It’s pumpkin season. This humble squash is virtually ignored from December through to the following September. But when fall rolls around it takes center stage again. For most of us, pumpkins show up as festive décor and baked into delicious pies in October and November. But there are plenty of reasons you ought to start...

Read This

Grow a BIGGER Brain with One Simple Move

Okay, I’ll admit I may have been accused of being a fathead a few times in my life. But I’ve got a secret. It doesn’t bother me one little bit. In fact, I take it as a compliment. After all, having a bigger brain is a GOOD thing, especially as we age. And now scientists...

Read This

Overlooked fatty acid SLASHES deaths and hospitalizations

I’ve sung the praises of omega-3 fatty acids many times here in Living Well Daily. I’ve encouraged you to be sure you’re getting enough of the omega-3s eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) by eating plenty of cold-water fatty fish and taking supplements when needed. And there’s a good reason for that. EPA and...

Read This

How Much Sleep DO You Need A Night? [STUDY]

I’m sure you know that getting enough sleep is good for you. But what does that mean, exactly? It’s always been hard to get a straight answer. Until now, that is. Thanks to new research we have an answer to that question. The newly published 25-year study compares the sleep habits of over 7,000 men...

Read This

MAILBAG: Is the Flu Shot RIGHT for YOU?

Dear Living Well Daily Reader, “Along with COVID, I’m worried about getting the flu this year. What do you recommend for avoiding the flu? The flu shot?” – Mike from Park City, UT Hi Mike, I’ll be honest. The flu vaccine COULD have a better long-term track record. According to the Centers for Disease Control...

Read This

Dangerous Vitamin Deficiency Sends Folks to An Early GRAVE

If you’ve been a loyal reader for a while now you’re probably already taking steps to ensure your health is in tip-top shape. You do your best to eat well… You stay hydrated… You, hopefully, get in some regular exercise… And maybe you even take a multivitamin… While I would certainly give you an A...

Read This

EASY 2-Minute Trick Fights Aging from Head to Toe

Healthy aging boils down to one surprising thing: your muscles. I know that may sound strange at first. But hear me out. Maintaining strong and healthy muscles is the first step to keeping a healthy body and sharp mind well into your golden years. After all, sturdy muscles are required to fight off frailty and...

Read This

Don’t Let Sickening BACTERIA Bungle Your Holiday Plans!

They say cleanliness is next to godliness. Now, I don’t know about that. But, I DO know that when it comes to your kitchen, cleanliness is absolutely VITAL. The trouble is, even the cleanest of kitchens can harbor some sickening hidden secrets. And new research just revealed one of the most surprising culprits. Trust me,...

Read This

Cold, flu, or COVID? EASY ways to spot the difference

Does developing a sniffle, sneeze, or cough practically cause you to panic these days? If so, you’re not alone. Many of us feel the same way. Gone are the “good old days” when you only had to worry if you were coming down with a cold or the flu. And, let’s be honest, we didn’t...

Read This

3 -Minute Countdown Method DEFEATS Diabetes

Dear Living Well Daily Reader, Make a cup of tea. Read a couple of pages in a book. Watch a silly cat video. There are a bunch of things you can do in three minutes. And now scientists say defeating diabetes could be one of them. If you’re struggling with blood sugar control, your doctor...

Read This