Chuck Norris (Sort of) Lays the Smackdown on N.Y. Attorney General
We’ve just entered a new phase of media pandemonium surrounding the battle between New York attorney general Eric Schneiderman and nutritional supplements…
… because Chuck Norris has elbowed his way into the fray.
Before we give the details, a little backstory in case you’ve already let this controversy slip past your radar (which was probably a good idea):
A couple months ago, the New York attorney general threw a hissy fit after a lab technician he recruited found some supplements from major retailers’ shelves were allegedly lacking in the nutrients they claimed to have.
The media squealed with delight. Fingers were pointed. Speeches were made…
… and it turns out the attorney general’s lab lackey did a downright lousy job testing the supplements in the first place. But that didn’t stop the AG from continuing to fight the good (for his career) fight, yipping like a Chihuahua and dragging other states’ AGs into the mix.
Enter Chuck Norris.
Rather than his usual roundhouse kicks to the face, he’s merely written a (sort of) strongly worded article. We’re assuming he did so on an outdoor desk facing a panoramic Texas vista, eyeballing his first draft with a steely-eyed gaze. Anyway, here’s the article if you want to read it.
Typical “common sense” crud, in my opinion, when the author’s No. 1 priority is avoiding offended feelings at all costs and scoring a perfect 10 on the “agreeability” scale.
I can feel myself getting too riled up for an objective breakdown of what’s wrong with ole Charles Norris’ breathless read, so I’ll let Jasmine LeMaster, our resident ingredient egghead, take over…
Unfortunately, Mr. Norris has missed two very important facts in the NYAG situation, making it appear worse than it is (at least for GNC).
Chuck writes: “Some bottles of ‘St. John’s wort’ and ‘valerian root’ tested negative for the herbs on their labels.”
However, The NYAG used DNA testing to identify the botanicals in the products.
The problem is DNA testing does not work on botanical extracts, because the DNA becomes degraded during processing. And we now know that all the GNC products tested were extracts, explaining why some of products tested negative.
And then Chuck writes that “GNC reached an agreement with [the NYAG] to adopt more stringent testing standards than the FDA requires,” which seems to indict GNC as guilty. However, he failed to mention that GNC did prove that the supplements in question contained the herbs they claimed on the label.
More so, in an open letter to the industry, the head of GNC states: “NYAG found no evidence in the course of the investigation that GNC deviated from the federal Food and Drug Administration Current Good Manufacturing Practices…”
Simply to appease the NYAG, GNC agreed on a settlement and will go above and beyond what the FDA requires for supplement testing.
Now, in Chuck’s defense… other than those two missing facts, his article is actually pretty spot on with a problem in the supplement industry: There are shady companies out there selling products filled with nothing but rice flour, or, worse, tainted with drugs.
But just to be clear, there are extensive federal regulations for the supplement industry, both for how the products are manufactured and what claims companies can make about those products.
Anyone who say it’s “unregulated” is wrong. And the fact that some companies don’t follow the regulations doesn’t mean the industry as a whole is selling unsafe, unproven snake oil.
Aside from the tacky move of putting his own name in the title of his own article, and posting a huge picture of his face at the start, Chuck has some good advice on how to spot quality supplements: Look for companies that use manufacturers with third-party certifications, like NSF. And research what you’re buying before you buy it.
First of all, we’re all aware that if anyone’s earned the right to refer to himself in the third person in an article title… and feature a giant photo of himself in the lead… it’s Chuck Norris.
Second, I disagree with the premise of something being “wrong” with the supplement industry. Reminds me of the old saw “The road to hell is paved with good intentions.” The same could be said for a smothering (and ultimately lethal) government.
The supplement industry is evolving like any other should: The market is given freedom to both sell and consume products. As consumers become more educated, and more demanding, businesses will respond with better service. More advanced technology (spurred into existence by market forces) will help both merchants and consumers get what they want.
In a perfect world, Chuck Norris would agree.
What about you? Write in (firstname.lastname@example.org) and let us know if you agree with Chuck.
Underground Health Researcher
View More Free Articles
I’ve sung the praises of omega-3 fatty acids many times here in Living Well Daily. I’ve encouraged you to be sure you’re getting enough of the omega-3s eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) by eating plenty of cold-water fatty fish and taking supplements when needed. And there’s a good reason for that. EPA and...
I’m sure you know that getting enough sleep is good for you. But what does that mean, exactly? It’s always been hard to get a straight answer. Until now, that is. Thanks to new research we have an answer to that question. The newly published 25-year study compares the sleep habits of over 7,000 men...
Dear Living Well Daily Reader, “Along with COVID, I’m worried about getting the flu this year. What do you recommend for avoiding the flu? The flu shot?” – Mike from Park City, UT Hi Mike, I’ll be honest. The flu vaccine COULD have a better long-term track record. According to the Centers for Disease Control...
If you’ve been a loyal reader for a while now you’re probably already taking steps to ensure your health is in tip-top shape. You do your best to eat well… You stay hydrated… You, hopefully, get in some regular exercise… And maybe you even take a multivitamin… While I would certainly give you an A...
Healthy aging boils down to one surprising thing: your muscles. I know that may sound strange at first. But hear me out. Maintaining strong and healthy muscles is the first step to keeping a healthy body and sharp mind well into your golden years. After all, sturdy muscles are required to fight off frailty and...
They say cleanliness is next to godliness. Now, I don’t know about that. But, I DO know that when it comes to your kitchen, cleanliness is absolutely VITAL. The trouble is, even the cleanest of kitchens can harbor some sickening hidden secrets. And new research just revealed one of the most surprising culprits. Trust me,...
Does developing a sniffle, sneeze, or cough practically cause you to panic these days? If so, you’re not alone. Many of us feel the same way. Gone are the “good old days” when you only had to worry if you were coming down with a cold or the flu. And, let’s be honest, we didn’t...
Dear Living Well Daily Reader, Make a cup of tea. Read a couple of pages in a book. Watch a silly cat video. There are a bunch of things you can do in three minutes. And now scientists say defeating diabetes could be one of them. If you’re struggling with blood sugar control, your doctor...
Dear Living Well Daily Reader, “I hate that I can no longer just eat whatever I want. I either seem to have indigestion, bloating, or gas. I’m always taking antacids. It’s miserable and frustrating — what else can I do besides only eating potatoes?” –– Carl, from Lincoln, NE Hi Carl, Let’s start with the...
Remember when they said we’d just need to hunker down at home for a few weeks, and this whole COVID-19 thing would blow over? It’s safe to say they got that one wrong. In fact, it’s looking like COVID-19 is less of a visitor and more of a permanent house guest these days. That means...