High Protein Wrecks Your Kidneys… Except It Doesn’t

In February 1977, a dense (in both meanings of the term) publication called “Dietary Goals for the United States” shot out of the cloistered halls of Congress and into the public mind.

It blithers and tortures the language as only government reports can. If you have trouble falling asleep, plow through the original’s typewritten pages here.

But its bottom-line recommendation was clear. Americans should eat more carbohydrate and less fat.

Obesity and Type 2 diabetes began ratcheting skyward almost immediately afterward.

The guidelines have shifted somewhat in the last few decades, but despite the horrific results of this report, official distrust of fat continues today — along with a distrust of fat’s common companion, protein.

The Recommended Daily Intake suggests that as part of a 2,000 calorie daily diet, adults take in just 50 grams of protein.

That’s about 1.7 ounces.

Because fat and protein are “bundled” in many healthful foods such as beef, eggs, and whole-milk cheese and yogurt, it’s easy to consume two or three times that amount of protein when following a high-fat, low-carb (HFLC) diet.

And a HFLC diet is the kind of diet that many scientifically informed health writers in 2015 – including, I daresay, me — recommend.

So what, exactly, is the hazard?

Why, too much protein destroys the kidneys!

This is yet another dietary “fact” that “everyone knows.” I used to think there was some truth to it myself.

But here’s the real story:

There is some evidence that people with established kidney disease should restrict their protein consumption.

However, diving into the scientific literature, it’s striking how resoundingly researchers have rejected the “high protein wrecks the kidneys” argument when it comes to people with normal kidneys:

“After an extensive review of athletes and others who consume high-protein diets, researchers concluded that when it comes to the kidneys — as well as to bone density, heart function, liver function, blood pressure, and lean body mass — no detriment was seen.” 1

Specifically, this study in Nutrition & Metabolism found that protein intakes up to 243 percent of the recommended amounts did not impair kidney  function.

Why? Coming to a similar conclusion, a Finnish researcher pointed out:

“The typical Paleolithic diet compared with the average modern American diet contained three-four times more protein. It is implausible that an animal that adapted to a high-protein diet for 5 million years suddenly in 10,000 years becomes a predominant carbohydrate burner.” 2

Word.

In fact, a high protein intake has been shown to lower blood pressure and help reverse Type 2 diabetes, and these are two of the biggest risk factors for kidney failure. 3

Bottom line: The truth is that low-fat, low-protein, high-carbohydrate diets are tough on kidneys. If you want to avoid kidney damage and a host of related ills, eat more fat — especially saturated fat — and protein and significantly less carbohydrate.

Regards,

Brad Lemley

Editor, Natural Health Solutions


1 William F Martin, Lawrence E Armstrong, Nancy R Rodriguez. Dietary protein intake and renal function. Nutrition & Metabolism. Sept. 2005

2 Anssi H Manninen. High-Protein Weight Loss Diets and Purported Adverse Effects: Where is the Evidence? Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. May 2004.

3 Altorf-van der Kuil W1, Engberink MF, Brink EJ, van Baak MA, Bakker SJ, Navis G, van ‘t Veer P, Geleijnse JM. Dietary protein and blood pressure: a systematic review
PLoS One. Aug. 2010.

Brad Lemley

Written By Brad Lemley

Brad Lemley is a science and health writer and former senior correspondent for The Washington Post and Discover magazine. He is a tireless advocate for safe, natural, self-directed healthy living practices and therapies.

View More Free Articles

MAILBAG: Slow Dementia Down with THIS “Sugar Fix”

Dear Living Well Daily Reader, My wife has recently begun showing signs of dementia. Her doctor has put her on medicine to try and “slow the progression” but, if anything, she seems like she’s just getting worse. Is there anything we can do? –Martin from Durham, North Carolina Hi Martin, Some medications claim to slow...

Read This

Common Weed Killer Causes IBD?

It always puzzles me how anyone thinks we can spray toxic chemicals on our crops and NOT have them affect our health! Because despite what food manufacturers may claim, chemical residues from pesticides and herbicides show up on (and IN) the conventionally grown food we eat. And research makes it clear that these creepy chemicals...

Read This

All-Natural Solution FIGHTS Vision Loss

I think you’ll agree that aging should come with some perks. And chief among them is FINALLY having the time to relax and enjoy the retirement you earned. But that’s awfully hard to do if you’re losing your eyesight due to macular degeneration. Instead, your golden years become tarnished by having to focus on learning...

Read This

Dodge Diabetes with THIS “Barnyard” Secret

How does that old saying go? An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. We all know it’s easier to STOP something from happening in the first place than to repair the damage after it’s happened. And with all of its complications, including shortening your lifespan, type 2 diabetes is well worth preventing!...

Read This

Gut Trigger Causes Arthritis? (WEIRD)

I’ve had patients make some pretty strange claims about their arthritis. Many folks swear they can “feel a storm coming” in their joints. And I’ve heard this one so often (and had them be spot-on about that storm) that I believe it’s true. Other patients claim their joint pain gets worse when eating tomatoes. And...

Read This

Common Heart Condition Sends Dementia Risk SOARING

If you’re “of a certain age,” I bet you remember that iconic old slogan from the late 70s, “A mind is a terrible thing to waste.” It always springs to mind when I see a sharp person’s memory start to fade away. They soon become unable to make decisions for themselves. Eventually, they even have...

Read This

MAILBAG: Protect Yourself Against New COVID Variants

Dear Living Well Daily Reader, “Most of my family has been hit with COVID. We’re thinking it’s the latest variant. Are there any extra, new recommendations for protecting yourself against the variant? (Aside from washing your hands?) My husband and I have tested negative so far, but we want to be careful.” –Tammy from Lancaster,...

Read This

Dial Down Blood Sugar Naturally [RIVALS Metformin!]

If you have diabetes, it’s almost certain that your conventional medical doctor put you on a blood sugar-lowering drug. And there’s ALSO a strong possibility that the drug makes you feel terrible. Common side effects include gas, bloating, upset stomach, kidney issues, and fatigue. Even worse, over time, these drugs become less effective. So even...

Read This

“Happiness Method” Slows Aging

Okay, I’ll admit it. There have been times I’ve found it tough to maintain an optimistic outlook these last few years. And I’m not alone. Studies show that unhappiness and loneliness are on the rise. That’s TERRIBLE news for our health. Because when you combine the two, it can deliver a devastating blow to your...

Read This

Belly Up to The Bowl for THIS New Nut Benefit

It’s the nuttiest time of year. And I’m not just talking about the decorating, shopping, and holiday chaos… I’m literally talking about NUTS. Sure, we eat these tasty treats all year round. But when the holidays approach our nut consumption goes through the roof. We eat more nuts from October through December than any other...

Read This